Disputed vote on plans for 26,000 homes for Northampton ‘was not legal’ – Politics – Northampton Chronicle and Echo

Conservative incompetence will lead to massive developments
Conservative incompetence will lead to massive developments

STITCHED UP by Political Hypocrisy or Incompetence?

Why didn’t they Stand Up and Speak Up when they had the chance?

When I finished my recent blog ‘STITCHED UP by Political Hypocrisy’ saying that I suspect this is not the end of this I wasn’t of course aware that there had been a breach of the Committee procedures.

The latest revelation in the Chronicle and Echo seems to be concentrating as have those who have made comments on it on the role of Cllr Over as the Chairman whose role was to use his casting vote.

But what of the role of the other members of the committee, surely they as experienced Councillors knew the rules and procedures for voting?

It is understandable that residents are angry and feel that they have been led up the garden path by those who are now fully implicated in the incompetence of the committee.

I have been consistent in saying that I have a great deal of sympathy with residents who are facing large-scale housing developments on their doorstep.

For those who have followed my past observations on the West Northamptonshire Joint Core Strategy (WNJCS) I have also been consistent in opposing the previous Government legislation that imposed over 55,000 homes on the area.

I have been consistent in speaking up making it clear that whilst we obviously need thousands of houses to provide homes for Northampton’s expanding population the growth should be based on ‘natural organic growth’ and not through imposition from Central Government.

What became very clear and was supported by ALL of the Borough Council political parties was that we believed that the number of homes needed was less than 55,000.

You would think therefore that the latest proposals of 41,760 would be welcomed as proof that local politicians were correct in opposing the imposed targets.

After all a reduction of 13,240 is a significant reduction.

Whatever the excuse it was incompetent not to know the rules
Whatever the excuse it was incompetent not to know the rules

The reality is that those who are now parading themselves as champions of the people are the very same people who not only had the opportunity to shape the proposals but should certainly have been aware of the committee procedures.

The Conservatives on 17 January 2011 put the following motion down to the Northampton Borough Council which I’m sure the reader will recognise was just before the Borough Council election.

MEETING OF NORTHAMPTON BOROUGH COUNCIL HELD AT THE GUILDHALL, NORTHAMPTON, ON MONDAY, 17 JANUARY 2011.
PRESENT: COUNCILLORS:
HER WORSHIP THE MAYOR Councillor (in the Chair).
Beardsworth, Capstick, Caswell, Chaudhury, Choudary, Church, Clarke, Collins, J Conroy, R Conroy, Crake, Davies, Flavell, Garlick, Glynane, Golby, Hawkins, Hill, B Hoare, Hollis, Larratt, C Lill, J Lill, Malpas, B Markham, I Markham, Mason, Matthews, Meredith, Mildren,

Councillor Larratt proposed and Councillor Golby seconded:
“This Council notes the view of the West Northamptonshire Joint Planning Unit
Council Minutes – Monday, 17 January 2011

WNJPU), endorsed by the West Northamptonshire Joint Strategic Planning Committee (WNJSPC) that a dwelling provision of between 45,000 to 48,000 (2001- 2026) would meet ‘natural growth’ of the existing population of West Northamptonshire. Council also notes the views of these bodies that adding local aspirations, particularly the growth of Daventry town suggests a requirement of 50,000 dwellings would be required throughout the area of West Northamptonshire.

This Council recognises the aspiration of the majority of residents of Northampton not to see this Borough have development imposed on it’s boundary by adjacent Local Authorities in order to meet the housing needs of those authorities areas. In particular, this Council recognises the views of a great many residents living in the Kingsthorpe area of the town who do not wish to see land at Buckton Fields developed to meet the housing needs of Daventry District.

In the interest of localism and the aspiration of many residents of Northampton, especially those living in the Kingsthorpe area, this Council calls on the WNJPU and WNJSPC to again review the housing needs of West Northamptonshire at the earliest opportunity and not to increase the provision of between 45,000 and 48,000 dwellings to 50,000 in order to meet the aspiration for additional growth in Daventry town.

Furthermore this Council calls on the WNJPU and WNJSPC to reallocate the dwellings proposed at Buckton Fields to Daventry town and remove the development site at Buckton Fields from all development plans, including the emerging Joint Core Strategy for the development of West Northamptonshire”.

Council debated the motion.
Upon a vote the Motion was carried.

There was a clear and unambiguous ALL party agreement on opposing the Buckton Fields Development which as we know was granted by the Daventry District Planning Committee all be it on a significantly reduced numbers of homes.

The number of homes proposed is 3,240 fewer than the minimum which was proposed by Cllr Phil Larratt and voted for by ALL of the Conservative Councillors present at the meeting.

People would be right to ask just how consistent have they been in their role in developing the Joint Core Strategy and at the same time opposing the very thing they have been as part of its development.

What is of interest to the residents opposing the SUEs is how the Conservative Councillors voted on the following Labour Motion that was put to the Northampton Borough Council on 9 July 2012

OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF A MEETING OF NORTHAMPTON BOROUGH COUNCIL HELD AT THE GUILDHALL, NORTHAMPTON, ON MONDAY, 9 JULY 2012.
PRESENT: COUNCILLORS:
HIS WORSHIP THE MAYOR Councillor Conroy (in the Chair).
Ansell, Aziz, Beardsworth, Begum, Bottwood, Capstick, Caswell, I. Choudary, N. Choudary, Davies, Duncan, Eales, Eldred, Flavell, Ford, Golby, Gowen, Hadland, Hallam, Hibbert, Hill, King, Lynch, Mackintosh, Malpas, Markham, Marriott, Mennell, Meredith, Nunn, Oldham, Palethorpe, Parekh, Patel, Sargeant, Stone, Strachan, Subbarayan, Wire DL and Yates.

Councillor Palethorpe proposed and Councillor Stone seconded:
“This Council notes that all of the current voting members of the West Northants Joint Strategic Planning Committee are Conservative.

The West Northants Joint Strategic Planning Committee (WNJSPC) oversees the development of the West Northamptonshire Joint Core Strategy (WNJCS). The WNJCS involves the delivery of 50,000 new homes in the West Northamptonshire area.

This Council also notes that the Conservatives on the WNJSPC have had a majority since it was created by statutory instrument in 2008.

This Council further notes a Conservative motion, carried on 17th January 2011, by
Council Minutes – 17 January 2011

Cllr Larratt and Cllr Golby stating,
„This Council calls on the WNJPU and WNJSPC to reallocate the dwellings proposed at Buckton Fields to Daventry town and remove the development site at Buckton Fields from all development plans, including the emerging Joint Core Strategy for the development of West Northamptonshire.

This Council also notes that the Conservatives have not removed the following from the emerging Joint Core Strategy.
Policy N5 – Northampton South SUE
Policy N7 – Northampton Kings Heath SUE
Policy N8 – Northampton North of Whitehills SUE

This Council asks the Leader of the Council at the next full Council meeting (September 2012) why this previous Conservative motion has not been upheld by his administration and also give the full rationale for the inclusion of Policy N5 and Policy N7 in the Joint Core Strategy despite the knowledge that there is strong local opposition in these areas.”

Council debated the motion.
Upon a vote the motion was lost.

I’m sure those interested groups and individuals will have noticed which Conservative Councillors were in attendance and that the Motion was lost because the Conservatives under the direction of the Leader of the Council voted against it.

In effect the Conservatives voted to support the WNJSPC which makes their now voting Against the proposals at the best confusing and at the worse hypocritical.

Some might say even dishonest and the recent revelations and challenge to the decision suggests incompetence by the members of the committee.

What people will also notice is the Absence at the meeting, presumably because he recognised that if he turned up he would have had to Vote, of Councillor Larratt.

If they felt so strongly about the proposals why didn’t they turn up, speak up and agree to change them?

It is a question that many, especially those living on or adjacent to the Northampton Borough Council boundary will be asking.

I have a great deal of sympathy for Councillor Chris Over who having taken the role as the Chairman from Cllr Hadland had to use his casting vote to make the decision and he is right to point out as he has that the Joint Core Strategy has been years in its development.

In fact it started when the Borough Council was under the leadership of Cllrs Larratt and Hadland.

All political parties throughout the process have agreed that it is imperative to have a plan and strategy without which the door would be open for speculative developers to submit planning applications and successfully challenge any refusal.

It is noticeable that the Leader of the Council, Councillor David Mackintosh who is not known for his reticence continues to remain silent on the whole issue.

Is it because he disagrees with the position taken by his colleagues who he appointed to the WNJPU?

or, and I stress this is only my opinion,

Is it because it doesn’t really affect his personal ambitions?

After all the majority of the proposals are either in the Northampton North or South Northamptonshire Parliamentary Constituencies and as such are a problem for Michael Ellis MP and Andrea Leadsom MP.

The Northampton South Constituency where he is standing in 2015 is relatively unscathed and unaffected by the proposals and therefore will not be a major issue in the run up to the election.

Except of course those who are affected will undoubtedly have friends and family who live in Northampton South.

What will be interesting is what representations will be put forward by the three Conservative led Councils of Daventry, South Northants and Northampton Borough Council who have been fully involved in developing the proposals.

It will also be interesting to see how individual Councillors explain how we have arrived in a position that Conservative ‘unanimity’ suddenly disappeared at the 11th hour.

What of course the latest revelation doesn’t explain is which Councillor actually failed to follow the correct procedure and register as a substitute in order to ensure a valid vote.

The Northampton Borough Council Conservative Councillors had they been doing their job, for which I believe they get an allowance from the tax payer, would have recognised the problem and in opposing the motion achieved their aim because the vote would have been 6 – 5 against.

I have added a list of the members and designated substitutes on the WNJSP and when compared with the attendance at the meeting on Monday 16 December 2013 it seems that the only substitute was Cllr Chris Millar the Leader of Daventry.

The minutes also show that it was Cllr Millar who proposed that the proposals should be accepted.

It is a shame that the blame is being directed at Cllr Millar by his NBC Conservative colleagues, as presumably their way of trying to cover their own incompetence, because he is in my experience one of a rare breed in Local Politics a Cllr who is totally honest.

Northampton Conservatives incompetence has led to Chaos
Northampton Conservatives incompetence has led to Chaos

Whatever the outcome of this whole sorry incident is that in any future re-vote the result may well, in fact quite probably be 6 – 6 again and Cllr Over will once again have to use his casting vote.

The opportunity for the Northampton Borough Council Conservatives supported by the County Council Conservatives to refuse the proposals has now gone.

and of course if the vote goes the other way the developers will challnge the whole process through the courts for which the tax payer will have to pay.

Residents in the SUE areas would do well to remember it when the developers move in.

WEST NORTHAMPTONSHIRE JOINT STRATEGIC PLANNING COMMITTEE.

Daventry District Council:

Cllr Alan Chantler
Cllr Cecile Irving-Swift
Cllr Chris Over

Cllr Deanna Eddon (substitute)
Cllr Mike Warren (substitute)
Cllr Chris Millar (substitute)

 

Northampton Borough Council:

Cllr Penelope Flavell
Cllr Tim Hadland
Cllr Phil Larratt
Cllr Jonathan Nunn

Cllr John Caswell (substitute)
Cllr Matthew Golby (substitute)
Cllr Alan Bottwood (substitute)
Cllr Brian Oldham (substitute)

 

South Northamptonshire Council:

Cllr Rebecca Breese
Cllr Stephen Clarke
Cllr Robin Digby

Cllr Mary Clarke (substitute)
Cllr John Townsend (substitute)

 

Northamptonshire County Council:

Cllr Michael Clarke
Cllr Andre Gonzalez de Savage

Disputed vote on plans for 26,000 homes for Northampton ‘was not legal’ – Politics – Northampton Chronicle and Echo.